Colorado Fiscal Institute Logo

The Forecast Five: Essential Takeaways from the December Revenue Estimates

Table Of Contents

Share this Post:

Five important takeaways from the Dec. 21 quarterly revenue forecasts:

 

Twilight Zone

1. Cutting during good times.

Colorado has one of the best economies among states in the country, but that economic growth doesn’t translate into increased state budget flexibility. Colorado had the fifth fastest-growing state economy (measured by GDP) from 2013 to 2014, and the state’s job market is outperforming most states, with unemployment at 3.6 percent compared to 5 percent nationally. This is the lowest unemployment in Colorado since Spring 2007. Nonetheless, Colorado’s state budget which ranks 49th largest among states (only Texas has a smaller state budget relative to its economy than Colorado) can’t harness that economic growth, which is resulting in cuts to state services this budget year.

 

 

 

 

Rainy Day

2. The General Fund Reserve was meant for times like these.

When the current fiscal year’s budget (FY 2015-16) was adopted in March 2015, our elected officials relied on projections of state taxes and fees. They also relied on projections for local property taxes and student enrollment. These have all changed since March. The end result is that the current budget is between $207.8 million and $156.6 million short of what was adopted in March. But because of lower enrollment growth among students in Colorado’s schools and increases in local property taxes, $159 million more in school funding was available than what was expected when the 2015-16 budget was passed. Legislators could use those additional local dollars to increase the K-12 budget and help reduce the $855 million shortfall in school funding known as the “negative factor.” This would also require tapping into the General Fund Reserve. But that’s what it’s for.

 

 

 

 

Butterfly Effect

3. There’s now a “Butterfly Effect” on the budget.

The complicated interactions between fee revenue, tax collections, constitutionally mandated rebates and money transferred to transportation and capital construction projects have really become apparent again this forecast period. When preparing next year’s state budget, elected officials essentially must make a gamble on a variety of scenarios based on very marginal changes in tax collections. Very small changes in forecasted state revenue can result in large changes in the amount of money available for budgeting this year and next.

 

 

 

Gallagher watermelon

4. Gallagher and TABOR don’t play nice together.

The residential assessment rate (which is applied to home values to determine property taxes) is projected to fall in 2017, which will further erode local support for schools and increase the reliance on state funding for education. The often conflicting and always confusing interaction between the Gallagher amendment and the TABOR amendment is once again working against well-funded public services. Gallagher provisions will drive down the residential assessment rate in 2017 after years of the TABOR amendment keeping the residential assessment rate lower than required by the Gallagher Amendment. Weird, huh?

 

 

Golf Clap

5. Small TABOR rebate in 2016, none the next year.

In Fiscal Year 2014-15, Colorado collected $156.5 million more in taxes and fees than TABOR’s revenue limit allows. When taxpayers fill out their taxes in early 2016 for the 2015 tax year, the average Colorado taxpayer will get an extra $18 from the state. The current revenue projections for Fiscal Year 2015-16 indicate that Colorado will not collect more in taxes and fees than the TABOR revenue cap allows, which means no rebates for taxpayers next year.

Share this Post:

Latest Insights

The Rent is Too Damn High

Why TABOR Makes Housing So Unaffordable in Colorado Colorado is now ranked the 6th least affordable state in the country, up from 8th last year. Across Colorado, people on fixed…
Read More

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

From tax reforms to budget updates, we break down complex issues to keep you informed on policy decisions impacting our communities.

Your support makes it possible for CFI to provide information that policymakers, community leaders, and residents need to make the best decisions for themselves and their communities.

Colorado Fiscal Institute © 2011-2025. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy

This website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and ensure the site functions properly. By continuing to use this site, you acknowledge and accept our use of cookies.

Accept All Accept Required Only